 |
manchester architecture - a guide to buildings in manchester |
 |
 |
The
worst buildings in the rock'n'goal capital of the world
|
Whilst we're extremely proud of many of Manchester's fine buildings,
there's some that have some how managed to sneak past the council's
quality control room. Worringly, from the votes we've received
so far, most tend not to be from the 1960's and 1970's but far
more recent projects from out-of-town designers. Every building
on this page though reflects a strict selection standard - they
have to be in the Manchester region and, more importantly, they
have to be nominated by you as being appalling.
|
|
 |
|
|
If the demolition of the original building that once housed the
Hacienda nightclub wasn't bad enough, the building that was erected
in its place in 2003 also upset a few people. Crosby City Homes
tried to recreate the rounded face of the former yacht warehouse
which greeted thousands of commuters into the city centre each
morning. Instead their twelve storey block of brick and metal
is an overpowering eyesore which looks out of place amongst the
attractive warehouses and locks that surround it. (also see Manchester's
best buildings) |
where
is it? Whitworth Street West |
where
can i find out more? crosbyhomes.co.uk |
|
 |
|
|
When
the 1996 IRA bomb looked to have destroyed the Arndale Centre,
many Mancunian 'Thank You's' were added to the messages of hatred
towards the Irish terrorists. As it happened the 1979 Wilson &
Wormersley designed shopping complex survived another day. The
largest building in the city with its shops, tower block, car
parks and bus station underwent a series of exterior redesigns.
The brilliant new footbridge linking it to the new Marks &
Spencer was designed by Manchester architects Hodder Associates,
and the horrible brick spiral car park ramp was replaced with
a modern steel one. Work is now underway on the outside of the
shopping centre. |
where
is it? Market Street and beyond |
where
can i find out more? manchesterarndale.co.uk |
|
 |
|
3)
one piccadilly gardens
|
Not necessarily the worst architecture in the city, but surely
the worst location for yet another boring brick and glass structure.
Developed by London's Argent Group and completed in 2003, this
eyesore of an office block has been built slap bang in Piccadilly
Gardens opposite the Portland Thistle Hotel and looks more like
a multi-storey car park. |
where
is it? slap bang in Piccadilly Gardens |
where
can i find out more? onepiccadillygardens.com |
|
 |
|
4)
great bridgewater street
|
No - this Stephenson Bell designed, Crosby City Homes built, monstrosity
was not built in the 1970's! The luxury apartments which look
more like a prison camp, was dumped on Great Bridgewater Street
in 1997. Incredibly, the Design For Homes Architect Group described
it as a 'positive statement about the future shape of urban areas'.
Were they for real!?! |
where
is it? next to Rain Bar on Great Bridgewater Street |
|
 |
|
|
Another new development in 2003 that's obviously taken its inspiration
from a run down 1980's inner city council estate. Bellway Homes
describe their City Point 2 luxury apartments as having a "a
dramatic and challenging exterior which emphasises the individuality
of its 181 apartments". We presume by the word 'challenging'
they mean to the eye, rather than for the builder!?! |
where
is it? Chapel Street, around the corner from Salford Station |
more
info? bellway.co.uk |
|
 |
|
|
Another awful effort from Bellway Homes rising under the eye of
the current council planners in 2003. Described in their advertising
blurb as "Three stunning buildings, individual design".
Whoever wrote that must have been given a free apartment inside
the building, which, in fairness, are quite nice.
|
where
is it? Chester Road roundabout at Castlefield |
where
can i find out more? bellway.co.uk |
|
 |
|
|
This incredibly ugly building sits opposite the wonderful building
which used to house the Paradise Factory nightclub. Interestingly
UMIST's multi-storey car park stands opposite. It's hard to decide
which building is the more ugly. Built recently... now there's
a surprise! |
where
is it? corner of Charles Street and Princes Street |
|
|
 |
|
8)
apartments opposite castlefield
|
The luxury apartments opposite Castlefield seem to be a disappointing
waste of opportunity. Having replaced a large stretch of derelict
land, the view from the luxury apartments over the Castlefield
basin is superb. It's a pity the same can't be said of the view
from Castlefield towards the horrible metal and glass building.
In fact the view from the ground floor apartments is equally as
bad - they overlook the brick wall of the viaduct. Another great
opportunity wasted. |
where
is it? opposite Castlefield, behind Atlas Bar |
|
 |
|
9)
premier lodge manchester gmex 2
|
Yet another recent addition to the 'anytown' collection of buildings
popping up all over Manchester. The new Premier Lodge that greets
visitors to the city at the end of the Princes Parkway has been
described by Urban Splash's Tom Bloxham as "the most vile
building". Many of you seem to agree. |
where
is it? Mancunian Way and Princes Parkway roundabout |
where
i can find out more? tom
bloxham interview |
|
 |
|
|
One of the most influential companies in the whole of Britain,
Granada Televison, are based in this ugly looking building. The
8 storey glass and slab block was built in 1962 by architect Ralph
Tubbs. The better highlights can be found on the roof; a spiral
stairway climbs up the transmitter mast whilst the large US-styled
typography of the broadcaster's name can be seen across the city. |
where
is it? quay street |
|
|
[vote
for your worst building here] [also
see the best buildings in manchester here]
|
 |
|
 |